Friday, May 27, 2011

A Brief History of Western Action RPGs



The action RPG is a genre that could thrive first and foremost in Japan, where influences of personal computer games often resulted in new interpretations on game consoles, thus benefiting a healthy melange of genre traditions. Mixtures like that were initially fewer in the West, due to the consoles and arcade games being marked mindless quick entertainment by an elitist home computer crowd for real deal hardcore simulations and RPGs, which were the domain of computers with lots of memory (for the time) to store all those stats. Yet early on there were a few attempts to adapt what was originally inherited from tabletop war games to a more responsive and involving model, and with the slow demise of slow-paced turn-based gameplay eventually ARPGs would catch on as a main stream genre also among Western developers.

The rise in popularity of the genre in modern times may deceive from the fact that it has truly ancient roots, and there is much confusion and oblivion about the actual early innovations. So, following up on our Brief History of 2D Fighting Games, we'll have a look at what was going on with the ARPG genre in the US and Europe over the decades. (I know a lot of you will be yearning for a parallel feature on Japanese games. Such a thing is bound to follow some day, but don't hold your breath just yet.)

Of course I am likely to be eaten by a grue for all the omissions and games I simply didn't know about. Everyone's got their own definition of what belongs in the genre, too, so please be nice when you point out to me all the games I've idiotically left out/falsely included. Please also note that I originally put this post together late in 2010, but ended up not posting it for a number of reasons. I haven't really followed the genre since then, so this is a history for the time until 2010.

Adventure (Atari 2600)


1980-1982:
  • Adventure is released for the Atari VCS in 1980. Yeah, it doesn't have The RPG Elementz(TM), but that doesn't mean it was not an important antecede for the Action-RPG genre. For the first time in an action game, players got to do adventurey stuff, exploring dungeons, finding keys and weapons. Probably exerted more influence on Zelda and the Japanese ARPG tradition than the western one, though, directly or indirectly.
  • Most of the very early computer RPGs have their roots in Dungeons&Dragons applications for big university mainframe computers, so it's hard to work out a timeline for them, but from 1980 to 1982 a lot of them have been ported to home computers, as well as some new, original games. Automated Simulations' (later Epyx) Dunjonquest series and The Sword of Fargoal, as well as Daniel Lawrence's Telengard still played out pretty much like "normal" RPGs with a time limit to your moves.
  • Dungeons of Daggorath did similar for the 1st person crawl (although it had a really interesting feature of a heartbeat sound indicating your level of fatigue and damage and at the same time giving a greater sense of urgency).
  • Also from Automated Simulations, Dragon's Eye combines boardgamey exploration with what can only be described as a fighting game with an ATB battle system, as little sense as that seems to make on paper.
  • The first batch of official Dungeons & Dragons games is released for the Intellivision, but only Treasure of Tarmin vaguely resembles an RPG/Adventure experience.
Dragon's Eye (Apple II)

1983:
  • Gateway to Apshai, an offshoot of the Dunjonquest: Temple of Apshai RPG series, is the first ARPG proper world-wide, predating even the Japanese genre forebears Dragon Slayer and Hydlide. Combat takes place in real-time with reliance on player skill, although there are also stats to be leveled up (which happens mostly automatically without offering any choices for the player), and there is a lot of loot to find in the dungeons. This being a pure dungeon crawler, only NPC interaction is missing from the modern standard formula.
  • Dandy by John Palevich is the progenitor to Gauntlet. It gets later remade as Dark Chambers in 1988.
Gateway to Apshai (C64)

1984:
  • Gemstone Warrior, SSI's first dabbling with the genre, is more of an action adventure by today's standards. The player once again explores dungeons and kills monsters in real-time and searches for treasures which amount to the score. There's item management and a limited supply of ammunition, but no experience system.
  • Icon: Quest for the Ring by the small and unknown developer Macrocom plays like a simplified Gateway to Apshai, but surprises with astonishing CGA techniques that avoid the typical ugly 4-color scheme and make for one of the best looking IBM-PC games of its time. According to a developer interview at MobyGames, the game was popular as a demo for graphic cards in Japan. Could it have been a direct inspiration for Zelda?
  • Also into adventure territory falls Knight Lore, which explores the isometric perspective (and later influences the use of the perspective in Adventures/RPGs in general, as well as Solstice and its successors in particular, which in turn inspires Landstalker and its sequels).

1985:
  • Origin Systems creates Autoduel, the first racing RPG. Eat that, Squaresoft's Racing Lagoon.
  • Also published by Origin Systems is Moebius: The Orb of Celestial Harmony. The game takes place in a vaguely far eastern fantasy setting, with a focus on martial arts training and a fighting game style combat system. The characters awkwardly walk around as profile pictures and the combat controls are horrendous, but the concept is nonetheless unique and interesting.
  • Gauntlet is released the same year. Though also not quite an ARPG in itself, it is save to assume that without Gauntlet, there would be no Diablo (and in consequence neither most other WARPGs we know today).
Auto Duel (C64)

1986:
  • Gemstone Healer, sequel to Gemstone Warrior.

1987:
  • Conceived as an RPG for dummies, David Joyner's Fairy Tale Adventure might be the first western game that fits all modern ARPG definitions without fail, finally causing some steam for the (nowadays) classical top-down ARPG in the west.
  • Dungeon Master brings 1st person real-time RPGs en vogue. With a fighting system based on intervals slightly resembling the later Final Fantasy ATB, it is also no "true" ARPG, though. Aside from a sequel, tons of games follow its formula for combat, among them Bloodwych (1989), Eye of the Beholder (1991), Black Crypt (1992), Lands of Lore (1993).
  • Macrocom delivers a follow-up to Icon with 7 Spirits of Ra. The game takes place in ancient egypt.
Faery Tale Adventure (Amiga)

1988:
  • Times of Lore (Origin Systems). The NPC interaction is as complex as you'd expect from an Origins game at that time, there's no character generation but a selection of three pre-built heroes, and the combat is fully realtime action. Might or might not be the first game with jiggle animation for the female protagonist.

1989:
  • Hero's Quest: So you want to be a Hero (later renamed to Quest for Glory because of legal issues with Milton Bradley's board game) at one hand was a typical Sierra adventure, but also featured different stats and classes for the characters, which have a huge influence on how the game is played, as well as action based combat.
  • Hillsfar is more like an RPG/Mini Game compilation. Arcade style combat takes place only in the Arena.
  • Windwalker is the sequel to Moebius and fares much better thanks to icon-based mouse controls.
  • Also: Gauntlet II.
Quest for Glory (DOS)

1990:
  • Darkspyre by Event Horizon Software could be seen as another antecede for Diablo, albeit with fixed dungeon layouts.
  • Origin's Bad Blood is similar to Times of Lore, but shifts gameplay even more towards action-adventure and is set in a postapocalyptic future where one of three mutant spies is sent out to investigate and avert human war plans.
  • In The Keys to Maramon, a spin-off of the The Magic Candle series, the player gets to chose between four characters and then has to protect the town of Maramon against invading monster hordes. The game features a day/night circle: At night all shops are closed and the fiends start storming in.
  • Quest for Glory continues with its first sequel, the main character can be imported in good, old-school RPG fashion.
Bad Blood (DOS)

1991:
  • Two games based on Norse mythology are released that year. In Dusk of the Gods, Event Horizon builds upon their groundwork laid with Darkspyre, while the Britains at Core Design put themselves on the genre map with Heimdall.
  • Conan the Cimmerian hails as the first licensed ARPG not based on a pen&paper or tabletop game. For combat the game switches to a fighting game-style 1-on-1 sideview.
  • Another licensed title, Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves, was adjusted to tie in with the Costner movie just in time, leaving an unfinished feel about the game. Released for Game Boy and NES, it is the first console exclusive western ARPG.
  • Gauntlet III: The Final Quest (Won't be mentioning any more episodes of Gauntlet beyond this. With the genre as developed and defined as it is by now, the series just doesn't cut it anymore.)
Dusk of the Gods (DOS)

1992:
  • Ultima VII makes first (very slight) concessions towards a more action-oriented combat by introducing realtime.
  • The big attraction of the year is Ultima Underworld, though, with its real-time rendered 3D world, predating even Wolfenstein 3D.
  • Event Horizon bring a direct sequel to their 1990 debut, called The Summoning, so in this year one of the last great 2D dungeon crawl ARPGs (for a while) meets the first great realtime-3D dungeon crawl ARPG.
  • Sierra releases Quest for Glory III.
Ultima Underworld (DOS)

1993:
  • Ultima Underworld II is released, but doesn't stray much from the paths laid out by the first game.
  • Event Horizon in the meantime explore more adventure-esque paths with Veil of Darkness (which in a way anticipates their much later game Sanitarium). This is their last game before closing and reforming as DreamForge Intertainment.
  • In Hired Guns by DMA Design a team of 4 cyber agents infiltrate futuristic complexes in real time over 4-splitscreen, similar to the Dungeon Master formula. Quite a stressful task for a single player, so the game also supports multiple players simultaneously. (For comparison, the first big Japanese multiplayer ARPG, Secret of Mana, was released the same year).
  • Only one year after the third part comes Quest for Glory IV.
Hired Guns

1994:
  • Warren Spector, formerly of Origin System, changes the world with System Shock and its genius mixture of RPG and FPS elements.
  • Probably through influences from Japan, western developers by now also seem to discover the console-style ARPG for themselves. SSI's Al Qadim: The Genie's Curse would have worked just as well on the Genesis or SNES
Al Qadim
  • Interplay for once releases an ARPG that isn't a straight port of a computer game, but adjusted to what they deemed suitable for the platform - J.R.R. Tolkien's Lord of the Rings Volume One for the NES has (other than shared source, art and music) little in common with its PC counterpart, which is a traditional turn-based RPG. With a party of up to five, each of which can be controlled by a human player, it has the highest simultaneous player count in an offline ARPG ever.
  • Blue Sky software delivers a console title as well, Shadowrun for the Genesis (while the SNES game is more like a traditional RPG in that, though realtime, player effort has little influence over the combat vs character stats).
  • King Arthur & the Knights of Justice shares many features with an ARPG, however it lacks a levelup system.
  • Heimdall 2 is also much more console-like than its predecessor and becomes an important title for Commodores Amiga CD32 console.
  • The main Ultima series now makes is full jump to a point&click based action RPG with platforming sequences, much to the dismay of old time series fans.
  • The Elder Scrolls: Arena in turn manages to build a bridge between the concepts of Ultima Underworld and classical fantasy world exploration.
System Shock (DOS)

1995:
  • As great a year 1994 was, the more dreary appears the slump in 1995. The only western PC title that comes to mind is Entomorph, which features an interesting setting but proves quite insignificant, gameplay-wise as well as on the market.
  • Things look a bit better on the console side. Squaresoft America sets up a development team to create Secret of Evermore, inspired by Japanese game mechanics (namely a combat system taken from Secret of Mana; but on the other hand also an ingredient-based magic system that resembles that of more recent Ultima episodes) but with an audiovisual design meant to cater to American gamers specifically.
  • Lucasarts creates Big Sky Trooper. The unique Sci-Fi action RPG falls under most people's radar for combining overly cutesy graphics with complex mechanics.
  • Ocean's Addams Family Values follows closely in the footsteps of The Legend of Zelda.
Big Sky Trooper

1996:
  • The Elder Scrolls: Daggerfall is likely the biggest RPG ever, in terms of sheer world size. YMMV once again whether it is an action- or a "true" RPG. My mileage says I won't mention any more main series entries, as now the demise of the turn based RPG in the west has begun to set in, and real-time combat loses its role as a distinguishing factor between the subgenres.
  • Most of all, 1996 is Diablo year (though some sources claim it was released in January 1997. We Europeans got it a bit later, anyway, so I wouldn't know), marking the end of the big RPG draught. The vast majority of western ARPGs to come will be influenced by Blizzard's megahit in one way or another. Love it or hate it, deny its RPG status, whatever: Diablo is the most influential game for the genre of the whole decade.
Diablo (Windows)

1997:
  • Lands of Lore II is released, other than the first game a pure ARPG with lots of FMV sequences and digitized graphics, filling 4 CDs.
  • Faery Tale Adventure also makes its comeback with part 2: Halls of the Dead.
  • The Elder Scrolls: Battlespire ditches the huge overworld and NPC interaction of its predecessors, so it almost plays like a straight action game.

1998:
  • Now the era of "Diablo clones" begins: Ancient Evil, Dink Smallwood, Hexplore (the latter featuring a voxel-based 3D engine and a party of four exchangeable characters).
  • Tomb Raider's mark on the industry also becomes clear: Bethesda Lara-fies their Elder Scrolls series with Redguard, the French RPG sovereigns at Silmarils bring Asghan: The Dragon Slayer (the Action-Adventure genre should start to return the favor the next year with Drakan: Order of the Flame).
  • After a long pause, the Quest for Glory series is concluded with its fifth and final installment.
  • Interplay releases Descent to Undermountain. Using the successful Descent engine and the even more successful AD&D license, the game is a huge disaster, often quoted as the most bug-infested retail game ever and/or the worst RPG ever.
Hexplore (Windows)

1999:
  • Ultima's main series turns 3D with Ascension, but after endless revisions from the groundup isn't the game fans wanted, they call it pejoratively an "action adventure". It also ships with lots of bugs, and receives many fan mods to fix its several flaws.
  • Lands of Lore III is released and considered the weakest title in the series as well.
  • More Diablo clones: Revenant, Darkstone, Clans.
  • The year is saved by System Shock II, once again the best thing since sliced bread.
  • Another mention deserves Silver, which combines Japanese-style inspired RPG flair with beat 'em up fights and mouse gesture special moves.
Ultima IX: Ascension (Windows)

2000:
  • Diablo II is released, and it would have completely rejuvenated the hype around its predecessor, hadn't it been going strong consistently over all the years, anyway.
  • Warren Spector continues to explore new grounds with his cyberpunk thriller Deus Ex, which gives more meaningful plot decisions into the hands of the player than any game before.
  • Also: Summoner for PC and consoles, Nox.

2001:
  • Piranha Bytes apparently takes any concepts that are salvageable out of the trainwreck that is Ultima IX (figuratively speaking), patch it all up with what they carried over from their pen&paper passion, and somehow make a great game out of that. The new German RPG prodigy is called Gothic.
  • No end to Diablo-inspiration in sight: Vampire The Masquerade: Redemption and Throne of Darkness (in a samurai setting).
  • But 2001 marks also the beginning of console hack&slay shovelware with Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance, an attempt to cash in with the biggest name in non-action RPGing at the time.
  • Also: The obscure Euro-only title Technomage that dreams of being Japanese; Dragon Riders: Chronicles of Pern, based on the fantasy novels by Anne McCaffrey.
Gothic (Windows)

2002:
  • With Divine Divinity by the Belgian Larian Studios and Dungeon Siege by Gas Powered Games, the Diablo worshippers start to create something more meaningful with their time.
  • Gothic gets a sequel, which manages to excel the expectations set up by the first game.
  • The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Rings, oddly enough not based on the recent movie, but the book
  • Only one month later EA brings The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers. This one is based on the movie, and other than the aforementioned one a straightforward hack&slash game.
  • With Arx Fatalis appears a spiritual successor to Ultima Underworld.
  • Also: Summoner 2, now only on consoles.
Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring

2003:
  • With the current console generation, "RPG Elements" (meaning: stats that grow over the course of the game) start to crawl in into all genres, distinguishing between "proper" Action RPGs and action games with RPG elements becomes more and more difficult. For example, Deus Ex: Invisible War is more linear than its predecessor and relies even more on player skill rather than stats, causing many to file it as an FPS.
  • More Hach&Slay with Dungeons & Dragons: Heroes, The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King.

2004:
  • Even more Hack&Slay: Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance II, Fallout is selling out with Brotherhood of Steel, Everquest gets a console hack&slay spin-off with Champions of Norrath, The core RPG cult classic Bard's Tale gets a remake that in no way pleases old fans, either, but can at least win a new niche audience with sarcasm and snide. And not to forget Forgotten Realms: Demon Stone, Knights of the Temple: Infernal Crusade and X-Men Legends (some of which also got sequels I'm not tracking any further).
  • More stuff to shove down the throats of point&click ARPG fans on the PC comes with Sacred and Beyond Divinity.
  • With Sudeki tries another game to emulate Japanese aesthetics, with mixed results.
  • The most significant entry of this year is Peter Molyneux' latest baby Fable with its good&evil mechanics and a visibly developing main character, despite keeping about 5% of the promises previously made by its creator.
  • The underdog gem Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines, by the troubled Troika Games, is one of the most RPG-ey games (in the classical sense) games to date. Unfortunately the developer shall soon go bankrupt, leaving the game unpatched with loads of bugs. Maybe the most extensively fan-patched game.
Sudeki (Xbox)

2005:
  • Bioware, by now known as the saviour of the WRPG, tries their hand at the slightly pretentious Asia-Fantasy story Jade Empire, fittingly with a martial arts beat 'em up fighting system, most likely their least loved game ever (maybe with the exception of the Sonic handheld RPG), although that of course still isn't too bad in Bioware terms.
  • Sequels to Dungeon Siege and Champions of Norrath (dubbed Champions: Return to Arms). In a similar mold fits Fate by Wild Tangent.
  • Sigma Star Saga (WayForward Technologies) for GBA mixes an RPG with Shmup stages.
  • D.W. Bradley, of Wizardry fame, makes a short and unfortunate comeback with Dungeon Lords.

Jade Empire

2006:
  • Gothic 3 ships as the most bug-ridden game since Ultima IX and completely forfeits the series' reputation. Publisher and developer part ways to set in motion their individual follow-ups.
  • Dark Messiah of Might and Magic revives another of the big ancient PC RPG series in a new subgenre. Console version/remake follows in 2008.
  • Also: Titan Quest.

2007:
  • CD Projekt from Poland land a surprise hit with The Witcher, based on the most popular Polish fantasy novel.
  • Less surprising but even more hit is Bioware's Mass Effect.
  • Hellgate: London tries to combine Diablo's collecting mentality with the FPS genre, but can't even dream to repeat its role model's success.
  • Been awfully long since the last norse setting. Cyanide Studios from France try to rectify this with Loki: Heroes of Mythology. Another French title, Silverfall, is a typical fantasy hack&slay for PC and PSP.
The Witcher (Windows)

2008:
  • Fable II is released and fulfills about half the expectations people had for its predecessor.
  • Fallout 3 brings an old core RPG fan favourite back in form of an FPS/RPG hybrid.
  • Also: Two Worlds by Reality Pump from Poland; Sacred 2.

2009:
  • Borderlands is also borderline FPS/ARPG.
  • Piranha Bytes rises again with Risen, only not quite as high as they stood before Gothic 3.
  • Venetica embraces The Legend of Zelda, though not without a solid shift towards stat-based RPG, and pairs it with the gorgeous views of fantasy Venice.
  • Sidescrolling ARPGs never really caught on with western developers, but now there's Aztaka, which by virtue of being unique(?) in this therefore is the only indie game included in here.
  • Also: Divinity II, Torchlight.
Venetica

2010:
  • Mass Effect 2, though sacrificing many of its predecessor's "RPG elements", becomes the most engaging RPG yet.
  • Arcania: Gothic 4 is likely to doom the series to mediocracy forever.
  • Fable III comes out by the end of the year.
  • The espionage RPG Alpha Protocol and Fallout: New Vegas stand in good old Obsidian (and Troika, as some of that company's former employees are involved) game tradition in that they waste a lot of potential with lackluster QA (more fateful with Alpha Protocol, less with Fallout).
Alpha Protocol

58 comments:

  1. Pretty good write-up! I see a lot of names that kinda make me go "Hmmm...should check those out..." :)

    ...and I'm guessing by the time Torchlight came along, you were tired of listing Diablo clones? ;)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hah! I've been meaning to add in Torchlight into the list, but completely forgot.

    But yeah, it isn't exactly what I'd call an essential game, either.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I remember reading somewhere that hexplore was originally intended as a new Gauntlet reboot - but ran into legal problems, so released without the license. This is why the characters in the game may seem strangely familiar

    ReplyDelete
  4. What about Dark Alliance & Norrath?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dark Alliance is listed under 2001.

    It was ill-advised to use the Baldur's Gate name for a Diablo-style game, but Dark Alliance and Norrath are NOT shovelware at all. They're excellent games.

    Also, Dink Smallwood is not a Diablo clone. It is very clearly inspired by the Legend of Zelda.

    Lastly, although roguelikes don't really belong on an action RPG list, Diablo owes its very soul to them. The original Diablo is little more than a real-time mouse-driven version of Rogue (and that's exactly why it was awesome).

    ReplyDelete
  6. What about them? They're on the list.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Ever heard of Icon: Quest For the Ring? (MS-DOS, 1984)

    ReplyDelete
  8. "Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain" might be worth mentioning, maybe even "Soul Reaver". Good article otherwise!

    ReplyDelete
  9. As everyone's got their own definition of what belongs in the genre, it would be nice to hear yours at the beginning og the list. My personal one is pretty close to what you wrote about "Gateway to Apshai" ("Combat takes place in real-time with reliance on player skill, although there are also stats to be leveled up"), which is why I was admittedly a bit surprised to see "Brotherhood of Steel" and "Dungeon Siege" on a list otherwise matches pretty well with my definition (unlike some other schemes which go as far to include titles like "Icewind Dale" or "Freedom Force" as Action RPGs), but in general I found it to be a very nice list.

    However, you might want to go over it again to check for errors, as I unfortunately also noticed an unusually large amount of typos, such as, with no claim of being exhaustive:
    univerity -> university (Dunjonquest)
    hearbeat -> heartbeat (Dungeons of Daggorath)
    wich -> which (Hero's Quest)
    J.R.R -> J.R.R. (Lord of the Rings Volume One)
    influental -> influential (Diablo)
    Bethesta -> Bethesda (Redguard)
    belgian -> Belgian (Divine Divinity)
    Deux -> Deus (Deus Ex: Invisible War)
    Molineux -> Molyneux (Fable)
    visably -> visibly (Fable)
    Troubled -> troubled (Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines)
    bancrupt -> bankrupt (Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines)
    Project -> Projekt (The Witcher)

    ReplyDelete
  10. Note: My former post was directed at Anym3 (you should all totally register, if only to make things less confusing), before I read Anym4's comment. Blogger has that weird habit of delaying anonymous posts.

    @Anym4: I would make concessions so far as to calling them excellent shovelware, but I admit I'm not beyond taking an unrightfully pejorative tone when talking about games that nearly bored me to death.

    @Anym5: Can't say I have, but it definitely belongs on there. Changed now!

    @Anym6: I consciously decided not to include Legacy of Kain. The old Action-Adventure vs Action RPG argument, so YMMV.

    @Anym7: Thanks for the corrections.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I'm not Anonymous, I'm Anym (as silly as that may sound). I always post as such pretty much everywhere and am not to be confused with actual anonymous posters. ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  12. Anym6 again (someday I'll register..): Guess you're right by excluding "Legacy Of Kain", all those "Zelda"-influenced games on your list got me a little confused. Does your definition of "Action RPG" include gaining expierience points by combat and expansive item-management (like in "Seiken Densetsu") versus a more linear character development and progression (as in "Zelda")? Maybe you could share your criteria with the rest of us.

    ReplyDelete
  13. If you only have stats and an inventory and cannot roleplay a character (the way you can in Fallout or Torment), I don't consider it an RPG or ARPG. It's an action game, an adventure game, an action adventure game or a dungeon crawler, or whatever. Is Team Fortress 2 an ARPG because there are item drops, character customization, an inventory, crafting and character classes? Maybe it is, according to the vague definition most people are using, yet it's never referred to as such!

    I use the following definition to determine whether or not a game could be called an RPG:

    "Role-playing games are games in which players assume the roles of fictional characters and collaboratively create stories. Players determine the actions of their characters based on their characterization, and the actions succeed or fail according to a system of rules and guidelines. Within the rules, players can improvise freely; their choices shape the direction and outcome of the games."

    Thus Fallout and New Vegas are both RPGs(*) -- even though one is isometric and turn-based and the other is an FPS -- whereas System Shock 2 is not. Singularity isn't that much different from SS2, yet I don't see anyone calling it an RPG of any sort. The usage of these terms is extremely haphazard and sloppy because they're not based on any clear principles. Often a game is considered an RPG or ARPG just because the publisher says so, or not considered one because the publisher never called it that.

    http://insomnia.ac/commentary/the_rpg_conundrum/

    (*) Well, this depends on how strictly you follow the definition. You can't improvise and have to pick from pre-determined choices, but I think it's appropriate to have some leeway.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Nice list...it brings memories back, although I miss Fallout(1997) and Fallout 2(1998).

    ReplyDelete
  15. I think Dragon Age 2 took over from Jade Empire as Bioware's most hated game.

    ReplyDelete
  16. You mention Baldur's Gate for Dark Alliance, but you don't have the originals in the list.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Nice list , though i have no idea of the release datesof these games , i played more than half of them ...
    Thanks for the blast from the past :)

    ReplyDelete
  18. Someone's forgetting about most of Bioware's work! some of the best RPGs of all time might be worth some mentions!
    Baldur's Gate 1/2
    KOTOR 1/2
    Neverwinter Nights 1/2
    and others: Icewind Dale, Planescape Torment, etc...

    ReplyDelete
  19. "More stuff to shove down the throats of point&click ARPG fans on the PC comes with Sacred and Beyond Divinity."

    Except Sacred and Sacred 2 are some of the best in the genre, second only to Diablo. I don't think it was shoved down our throats at all...

    ReplyDelete
  20. Some people somehow missed that this list is only about ACTION RPGs....

    @Anym-not-anonymous: Heh, that got me confused good.

    @Anonymous-toomanytocount: There's no single set of criteria applied to the whole list. I've been much more lax for the early years, when many games were stumbling around trying to find new formulas. I wouldn't have mentioned Dungeon Master if it had been released after Diablo, for example.

    @ghost4: Defining CRPGs by the literal meaning of role playing nowadays is about as productive as running around and telling people that mosquitos actually don't bite. Can be an eye-opener at times, but for general usage, that train has left. It also doesn't take into account their history.

    Btw, interesting quote from Computer Gaming World #76 (November 1990), by Roe R. Adams III, author of Wizardry IV: "When The Legend of Zelda burst upon the scene in fall of 1988, it hit like a nova. Although it still had many action-adventure features, it was definitely a CRPG."

    ReplyDelete
  21. Alternate Reality ( city and dungeon ) should be on the list as they not only were they realish time with full day/night cycles, it was the first raycast game, years before Wolf3D and Ultima Underworld.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Somehow you managed to miss two of the most revolutionizing Western Action RPGs of the decade: Morrowind and Oblivion. The only reason I could think for you to do such a thing is to make your point hold water, which it does not. Unless you just consider the Action without Adventure, the WAAPRG (Western Action Adventure Role Playing Game) genre is not dying, but evolving to something so much more.

    ReplyDelete
  23. The point of the article is that the genre is dying? Funny, I thought the point was to show a brief history of Western Action RPGs.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Gotta nitpick a bit here: When System Shock was released, Warren Spector wasn't "formerly" of Origin Systems - he didn't leave until 1996 or so. He was the Origin producer for that Looking Glass-developed game. And Warren is the first to tell everyone that other people deserve more accolades for the Underworlds and System Shock, like Doug Church for example.

    ReplyDelete
  25. What about the fallout games?

    ReplyDelete
  26. "Planescape: Torment" and "Oblivion"?

    ReplyDelete
  27. That was an interesting read. I'm surprised Fallouts 1 and 2 didn't make an appearance, however, and especially Anachronox.

    ReplyDelete
  28. I found this post on Kotaku, it's a pretty good blog post, I found out about a lot of games I never heard of. Also on Kotaku, some guy is tard raging over Mass Effect 2 being on the list :p

    ReplyDelete
  29. @Velkyn: Oh! I somehow managed to not call them Diablo clones, but still ended up using a mean expression. Sorry!

    @Anonymous-that-mentioned-AlternateReality: Gonna have to check them out.

    @Jakey Bee: I didn't miss them. When I listing Daggerfall, I said I'd skip the regular sequels, since after turn-based went down the gutter, I'm not so sure if they're still at the "action" end of the spectrum. Might have been the wrong call, though. While the Kotaku headline suggests something like this, I make no such point that the history might be over. Also, what's revolutionary about Morrowind and Oblivion?

    @TerokNor: Good to know.

    @Everyone else: Please read the headline, or -heaven forbid- even the introduction. Fallout, Planescape Torment, Baldur's Gate (PC) are not ARPGs.

    ReplyDelete
  30. The Diablo - Gauntlet influence seems overblown to me, but apparently lots of people make that connection.
    And I'm guessing the Dragon's Eye shot was mislabeled, and it shows the Atari-version?

    ReplyDelete
  31. Pool of Radiance, Curse of the Azure Bonds and Secret of the Silver Blades was an RPG arc from SSI out the same time as Hillsfar, and far more ARPG than Hillsfar. Surprised you missed those.

    Also really important: Star Trek 25th Anniversary Ed. -- player takes the role of Kirk, included space combat as well as adventure/combat with a landing party. Ditto for Star Trek: Judgement Rites, the sequel.

    ReplyDelete
  32. As far as PC games are concerned, those Star Trek ones are like 95% point-and-click adventure and 5% weird Wing Commander simulation. I don't know about the console ports (I think there's an NES one that's totally different), but they are definitely not RPGs.

    ReplyDelete
  33. The action-RPG genre has to be my personal favourite. Just glancing through your images makes me feel extremely nostalgic. Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  34. "Mass Effect 2, though sacrificing many of its predecessor's "RPG elements", becomes the most engaging RPG yet."

    I love how one sentence caused such rage.

    ReplyDelete
  35. What's your stance on MMOs? I'd argue that most of the fantasy genre isn't actiony enough (with the possible exception of Age of Conan, which I haven't played), same with City of Heroes. DC Online is TOO actiony, having more in common with sandbox-with-RPG-elements games like Crackdown and Infamous. Champions and Star Trek, though, I would say fall into the sweet spot of "action RPG." The combat is real time, but your stats affect things like accuracy. There's NPC interaction and stat/equipment management, crafting (however rudimentary and unsatisfying) and in STO's case a hell of a lot of exploration to do. Neither game is something I could exactly see myself paying $15 a month for, but I think both successfully meet your requirements.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Seems like I unwittingly completely ignored them. I think Tabula Rasa would fit the bill, too. (Man, did I hope for the game to be any good. Back then it almost seemed like it could redeem MMORPGs for me.)

    ReplyDelete
  37. @DA and whoever else mentioned it

    Star Trek 25th on the NES is kinda like... a multi-character sci-fi Crystalis with phasers? Not really Zelda since you meet and talk with people and go in bars and stuff.

    I don't know what genre you'd classify it as, but since some have mentioned it I thought I'd chime and say it's pretty cool:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yePQOgECfi0

    ReplyDelete
  38. This article is depressing.

    It only serves to highlight two things:

    1) Games have become less hardcore despite mixing genres, and hack&slash/slay is favoured over any semblance of real combat.

    2) Almost no-one is making FIRST PERSON IMMERSIVE SIMS any more.

    Bollocks. :(

    (But great effort on the post Derboo. Though you've missed Towers 2, Shadowcaster, and Stonekeep.)

    ReplyDelete
  39. Ehm.... First things first, congratulations on a great article..

    My comments :
    1) As already mentioned, Roguelike games should be more mentioned, at least the early ones which were the clear model for Diablo 1..
    2) I'm shocked to read that Jade Empire is one of Bioware's most hated games... Dunno where that comes from but for what it is, it's a GREAT game and unique.. And an RPG too ofc..
    3)Titan's Quest and Torchlight just "mentioned" ? !!!!!!! Probably the 2 most loved Pure Diablo clones and only a simple mention .. Whatever..

    ReplyDelete
  40. You want to put the Captive series in there too, particularly the second one, Liberation; it had a similar interface to Hired Guns -- and came out the same year, as I recall -- but was more of a sandbox, putting the player in the role of a group of detective robots, scouring the city on the trail of captured political dissidents.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Interesting article, although with some imperfections:
    - Ultima Underworld came the same year as Wolfenstein 3D and the latter doesn't use true 3D however. Apparently an early presentation of the UU engine prompted John Carmack to code something less complex but, for the same reason, requiring lower system specs.
    - Why the first Lands of Lore (1993) isn't mentioned? Doesn't it fir the criteria? Its combat is real time.
    - Also no mention of Nox among the many 1999 Diablo clones?
    - Arx Fatalis was released in late 2002.

    Other than this, excellent retrospective, I am especially curious about Origin's early entries in the subgenre.

    @Casimir: I think Shadowcaster has hardly RPG elements in my opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  42. kelvingreen: Never heard of any of them. Gotta check them out.

    Gendo Ikari: UU and Wolf3D are from the same year, but AFAIK Origins game came out first?

    Lands of Lore is in, but not in its own entry but one of several games mentioned after Dungeon Master, that are also in real-time but not all that action-oriented and feel more like active turn-based.

    Nox ended up in 2001 for some reason. I think the real date is 2000, though? I might also have accidentally used the Xbox release date for Arx Fatalis. Gonna correct those soon.

    Also, while I might have mentioned Rogue when talking about Diablo, its influence has little to do with the action elements in the latter.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Thanks for the great article!

    One of my early rpg memories was "Castle of the Winds" (early 90's Windows game). I'm not 100% sure it belongs here, but it sure packs some nostalgia for me and a few of my friends.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Venetica must have slipped under my radar. Based on your description it seems like it's worth researching.

    @Anym : Project -> Projekt (The Witcher)

    CD Projekt is how they spell their name, they're Polish.

    ReplyDelete
  45. It's been mentioned before, but wasn't really followed up, but "Freedom Force" probably deserves some sort of mention.

    It's a real-time top-down super-hero game with stat growth and the ability to create custom superheroes. That, along with its refreshing and tongue-in-cheek setting definitely makes it worth a mention.

    ReplyDelete
  46. I wouldn't be so sure about Gateway to Apshai being the first action RPG, because that same year, another action RPG called Bokosuka Wars was released in Japan.

    However, the RPG elements in both games seem very limited compared to true action RPGs like Dragon Slayer and Hydlide released the following year.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Bokosuka Wars isn't an action RPG, it's a real time strategy game. As far as I can discern, there are no RPG elements whatsoever in the game.

    In what way are Dragon Slayer and Hydlide supposed to surpass the "RPG elements" of Gateway to Apshai?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Can you uploading Violent Vengeance - The Universe Hero (宇宙英雄 / 우주영웅) in Accend Inc games, please derboo?

      Delete
  48. Somebody actually mentioned ShadowCaster!!

    ReplyDelete
  49. Very nice post. But I don't see Baldurs gate in your list. Did you forgot it?

    ReplyDelete
  50. About Bokosuka Wars, the original PC versions did have some statistical RPG elements, but these were significantly watered down in the vastly inferior NES console port. Nevertheless, you're right that it's more closer to a real-time strategy than an RPG, though the NES port just made it seem like a poor action-adventure instead.

    As for Gateway to Apshai, what I meant about the limited RPG elements is that, what I've seen from videos, the stats or level don't seem to increase by continuous fighting/grinding, but by collecting items or clearing a level of the dungeon, which to me would make it more closer to an action-adventure like Zelda. But otherwise, I'd have to agree that it does more or less anticipate some of the action-RPG elements we see in Dragon Slayer a year later.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You forgot Shadow Fighter, Body Blows series, Elfmania, Fist Fighter, Capital Punishment, Fatal Impact, Human Killing Machine, and Fighting Spirit for Amiga system, Jagger.

      Delete
    2. What? Those are all fighting games...

      Delete
    3. Yes. Upload all the fighting games. You forgot Fatal Noise: Fighting Cancer Amiga, Jagger.

      Delete
  51. OK, the timeline you made is pretty comprehensive, but you didn't mention Rogue or Hack, two (highly influential) early eighties Linux games programmed by Americans?

    ReplyDelete
  52. Rogue and Hack were both turn-based.

    ReplyDelete